Uploaded image for project: 'i2b2 Core Software'
  1. i2b2 Core Software
  2. CORE-248

Obfuscated results missing indicator (± 3) when viewed by non-obfuscated user

Details

    • Bug
    • Status: Reopened
    • Major
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • 1.7.05
    • TBD
    • CRC Cell
    • None
    • Graph Results, Show Query Status
    • Analysis Breakdowns, Analysis Breakdowns - Graphs, Obfuscation
    • i2b2 Web Client
    • All Web Browsers
    • Hide
      This can be reproduced in both the i2b2 demo and test environments.

      STEPS TO REPRODUCE:

      1. Log into the i2b2 as an obfuscated user (no role above obfuscated is associated to your user).

      2. Run a query, making sure you check off all the breakdowns.

      3. The results will be returned and the obfuscation indicator will appear correctly in the Show Query Results.

      4. Now log into the i2b2 as a non-obfuscated user who is also a manager so you can see the previous query run by the obfuscated user.

      5. Drag the obfuscated query to the Query Tool and drop it at Query Name.

      6. The results of the previous query will display in Show Query Results and Graph Results.

      7. Notice there is no indication that these results are obfuscated.
      Show
      This can be reproduced in both the i2b2 demo and test environments. STEPS TO REPRODUCE: 1. Log into the i2b2 as an obfuscated user (no role above obfuscated is associated to your user). 2. Run a query, making sure you check off all the breakdowns. 3. The results will be returned and the obfuscation indicator will appear correctly in the Show Query Results. 4. Now log into the i2b2 as a non-obfuscated user who is also a manager so you can see the previous query run by the obfuscated user. 5. Drag the obfuscated query to the Query Tool and drop it at Query Name. 6. The results of the previous query will display in Show Query Results and Graph Results. 7. Notice there is no indication that these results are obfuscated.

    Description

      When an obfuscated user runs a query the results (including breakdowns) will have a ± and a pre-defined number to indicate the results are obfuscated.

      In the i2b2 demo data obfuscated results will appear as follows:

      Number of patients: 8±3


      THE ISSUE:
      The problem is this indicator does not appear if another user who is not an obfuscated user views the results of this query the obfuscation indicator does not appear in Show Query Status or Graph Results. The non-obfuscated user has no way of knowing those results are obfuscated.

      For an obfuscated user the number of patients will appear as: 8±3
      For a non-obfuscated user viewing the same previous query the results will appear as: 8

      There needs to be some type of indicator to all users that the results are obfuscated; Not just obfuscated users.

      Attachments

        Activity

          jmd86 Janice Donahoe created issue -
          jmd86 Janice Donahoe made changes -
          Field Original Value New Value
          Fix Version/s 1.7.07 [ 10203 ]
          Reproduction Notes This can be reproduced in both the i2b2 demo and test environments.

          STEPS TO REPRODUCE:

          1. Log into the i2b2 as an obfuscated user (no role above obfuscated is associated to your user).

          2. Run a query, making sure you check off all the breakdowns.

          3. The results will be returned and the obfuscation indicator will appear correctly in the Show Query Results.

          4. Now log into the i2b2 as a non-obfuscated user who is also a manager so you can see the previous query run by the obfuscated user.

          5. Drag the obfuscated query to the Query Tool and drop it at Query Name.

          6. The results of the previous query will display in Show Query Results and Graph Results.

          7. Notice there is no indication that these results are obfuscated.
          Assignee Mike Mendis [ mem61 ]
          i2b2 Sponsored Project/s i2b2 Web Client [ 10197 ]
          Status New [ 10000 ] Open [ 1 ]
          jmd86 Janice Donahoe made changes -
          Assignee Mike Mendis [ mem61 ] Nich [ nich ]
          nich Nich added a comment -
          Discussed with Mike on the behavior. Non-obfuscated users dragging over a query run by an obfuscated user should see the actual non-obfuscated results. Also, non-obfuscated users should never see +/- 3 in any of the results.

          There seems to be a defect in the CRC for a non-obfuscated user loading a previous query from an obfuscated user.
          nich Nich added a comment - Discussed with Mike on the behavior. Non-obfuscated users dragging over a query run by an obfuscated user should see the actual non-obfuscated results. Also, non-obfuscated users should never see +/- 3 in any of the results. There seems to be a defect in the CRC for a non-obfuscated user loading a previous query from an obfuscated user.
          nich Nich made changes -
          Component/s CRC Cell [ 10035 ]
          Component/s Web Client [ 10046 ]
          nich Nich made changes -
          Assignee Nich [ nich ] Mike Mendis [ mem61 ]
          nich Nich added a comment -
          This looks to be a CRC issue.
          nich Nich added a comment - This looks to be a CRC issue.
          nich Nich made changes -
          Resolution Incomplete [ 4 ]
          Status Open [ 1 ] Resolved [ 5 ]
          jmd86 Janice Donahoe made changes -
          Fix Version/s 1.7.07 [ 10203 ]
          Re-opening issue to Move it to the i2b2 Core Project to be evaluated by the developer.
          jmd86 Janice Donahoe added a comment - Re-opening issue to Move it to the i2b2 Core Project to be evaluated by the developer.
          jmd86 Janice Donahoe made changes -
          Resolution Incomplete [ 4 ]
          Status Resolved [ 5 ] Reopened [ 4 ]
          jmd86 Janice Donahoe made changes -
          Component/s CRC Cell [ 10049 ]
          Component/s CRC Cell [ 10035 ]
          Key WEBCLIENT-128 CORE-248
          Affects Version/s 1.7.05 [ 10164 ]
          Affects Version/s 1.7.05 [ 10163 ]
          Workflow Web Client Issues Workflow [ 10851 ] i2b2 Issues Workflow [ 11566 ]
          Project i2b2 Web Client [ 10033 ] i2b2 Core Software [ 10034 ]
          jmd86 Janice Donahoe made changes -
          Fix Version/s 1.7.09 [ 10306 ]
          jmd86 Janice Donahoe made changes -
          Fix Version/s 1.7.09 [ 10306 ]
          jklann Jeffrey Klann made changes -
          Fix Version/s 1.7.12 [ 10901 ]
          rm302 Reeta Metta made changes -
          Fix Version/s 1.7.13 [ 10902 ]
          Fix Version/s 1.7.12 [ 10901 ]
          rm302 Reeta Metta added a comment -
          will be fixed as :
          any query ran as obfuscated user will be flagged as obfuscated ( for any user view)
          rm302 Reeta Metta added a comment - will be fixed as : any query ran as obfuscated user will be flagged as obfuscated ( for any user view)
          rm302 Reeta Metta made changes -
          Fix Version/s TBD [ 11005 ]
          Fix Version/s 1.7.13 [ 10902 ]

          People

            mem61 Mike Mendis
            jmd86 Janice Donahoe
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated: